Bill James was noticeably silent about the steroid controversy in major league baseball until he recently released a 4-page paper on the subject titled, “Cooperstown and the ‘Roids“. As expected, James calmly addresses the issues and logically dismisses the fever that today’s media has bestowed upon this issue. He breaks his argument down to the following points:
- Steroids help players defy age, something he feels everyone will be doing (albiet with safer drugs/prescriptions) sometime in the future. These future “steroid” users will look back at this and say, “so what.”
- You can’t deny everyone (Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, etc) tied to steroids entry into the Hall of Fame. Eventually someone will break in, setting a precedent for others to follow.
- “History is forgiving. Statistics endure.”
- Ex-players influence Hall ballots and as more and more teammates of alleged steroid users get voted in, they’ll champion their teammates’ credentials
- “Is it cheating if one violates a rule that nobody is enforcing, and which one may legitimately see as being widely ignored by those within the competition?”
Overall I agree with James’ thoughts here. Over time, this debate will fade and stats will take over. This paper is well worth the read.
On a side note, James talks about Will Clark–one of my favorite players as a kid–and his rivalry with Rafael Palmeiro. He states (assuming Clark did not use PEDs), “I think that Will Clark has a perfect right to feel that he was cheated out of a fair chance to compete for honors in his time… But at the same time, I do not believe that history will look at this issue from the standpoint of Will Clark… What it seems to me that the Will Clark defenders have not come to terms with is the breadth and depth of the PED problem…”, but later adds when referring to point 2, “I only hope that, when all of these players are enshrined, they will extend a hand up to a few players from the Will Clark division of the game.” I can’t agree more!